Saturday, January 28, 2012

Matt Yglesias Is Wrong About Copyright

Oh, but Caleb, you will say. A lunch is different than an electronic copy of a work of art. And I would answer, Yes, that's true, but that's a separate issue, which I'll get to in a moment. The rationale quoted above depends in no way on the nature of what is taken. It's merely a claim that the economy-boosting spending potential of a thief is not necessarily impaired by his theft, and it can justify, or at least minimize the harm of, the theft of anything, abstract or concrete. It depends in no way on the nature of what is taken. Let's try taking Yglesias' laptop, for example. Here we go. ... Great! Now I have a new laptop. And the money that I was going to spend upgrading mine, I'm now free to spend on a new bicycle! Somebody in Portland will hand-make it, probably. A hipster has been given a job! Yglesias' laptop is my new bicycle! The Internet is so much fun.

Source: http://feeds.slate.com/click.phdo?i=6b9eac2a08a3a776ab52169e99705405

friday night lights christina hendricks emmys emmys tom bosley nina dobrev nina dobrev

No comments:

Post a Comment

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.